Sunday Supper Club: Edition No. 2 Thanksgiving Leftovers & Advent

Welcome back to the Sunday Supper Club, friends! I hope your Thanksgiving was full of joy, warmth, and oodles of blessings… and, if your fridge looks anything like mine, there's quite a few leftovers too. This week, we’re taking all that post-holiday goodness and turning it into a cozy, intentional meal to kick off the First Sunday of Advent. If you missed Edition One, definitely go back and read it—it has all the starter tips on how to launch your supper club, set your rhythm, and create a space that feels hospitable and prayerful.

This Week’s Menu: Thanksgiving-Leftover Inspired

Instead of letting those containers sit forgotten, let’s reimagine them:

Turkey, Sage & Gruyère Paninis

Warm, melty, and perfect for a simple Sunday supper.

• Take thin-sliced turkey, leftover herbs, and that last wedge of cheese pressed between buttery sourdough.

Harvest Autumn Salad

Easy, colorful, and feels like fall giving a final hug.

• Mix leftover roasted veggies (brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes, carrots—whatever you’ve got), add fresh greens, cranberries, pecans, and toss with a light vinaigrette.

Mashed Potato Croquettes

Crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside.

• Mix mashed potatoes with shredded turkey or ham, roll into little ovals, coat with breadcrumbs, and pan-fry. Serve with a dollop of leftover gravy.

Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake Jars

It tastes like you planned it all along.

• Layer broken pieces of leftover pie (yes, truly!) with a quick cheesecake filling—cream cheese, whipped cream, and honey.

Which of these are you most likely to make?

• Turkey Paninis
• Autumnal Salad
• Mashed Potato Croquettes
• Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake

Outfit Inspo: First Sunday of Advent

Since Advent begins on Sunday, November 30, 2025, let’s lean into the theme of hope, quiet expectation, and of course—liturgical purple.

Casual Look:

Think: cozy, welcoming, ready-to-host without overthinking it.

• A soft, oversized cream sweater

• Dark wash jeans

• Plum or lavender scarf for that Advent nod

• Comfy ankle boots.

Dressy Look:

Elegant, subtle, and perfect for marking the beginning of a sacred season.

• A deep violet midi dress (or even charcoal with purple accents)

• Paired with gold jewelry

• Simple heel or nice boot

Advent-Themed Table & Home Atmosphere

Let your Sunday dinner space reflect the beauty of the new liturgical year:

• Color Palette: Purples, deep blues, soft neutrals, and candlelight.

• Decor: If you have an Advent wreath, make it the centerpiece. Add small evergreen clippings, pinecones, or simple glass votives around it.

• Touches of Thanksgiving: A few leftover gourds or your pretty fall napkins still totally work! I'm thinking “late autumn meets quiet Advent.”

• Music: Gentle instrumentals or Advent hymns in the background—just enough to warm the room.

  
  

Some food for thought as we enter into Advent. As you wrap up your Sunday Supper Club this week, don’t forget to bring your Advent wreath to be blessed if your parish offers it—or simply ask a priest after Mass. When you gather for dinner, take a moment to pray together as a family or friend group, and invite one member of your supper club to light the first candle. It’s such a simple but meaningful way to mark the beginning of a season of hope.

And a gentle reminder that even though I’ve shared ideas for outfits, décor, and dinner inspiration, what matters most in hospitality and kinkeeping has nothing to do with having the “right” things. It’s all about showing up with a generous heart, making people feel seen and welcome, and creating space for shared prayer and connection. Those three things cost nothing—and they’re the reason Sunday Supper Club is worth doing in the first place.